In 1944, Haigh got into an automobile accident and he suffered an injury to his head. He claimed this was the reason for his nightmares again. Soon after this, he set up his workshop on 79 Gloucester Road, London SW7, in a rented basement.
His first victim was none other than William McSawn, his former employer who he happened to meet at the Goat pub, Kensington.
He met McSwan and his parents, Amy and Donald. They had rental properties in London and McSwan used to collect the rent on their behalf. Haigh became envious and greedy for money. He abducted McSwan on September 6, 1944, hit him on the head, and took him to his basement. There, he threw his body into a tub of sulphuric acid and two days later, he poured the “sludge” into a manhole. Haigh can be contrasted to Ed Gein, who used to exhume bodies so that he could used their skin and skulls.
After providing false information of McSwan’s disappearance to Donald and Amy, and taking over McSwan’s house, Haigh began collecting the money from their properties. They were confused as to why their son had not yet returned, so Haigh took them to his basement for a “surprise visit” on 2nd July 1945. He murdered them in the same way, sold their property, stole their pension checks, which amounted to 8000 pounds and then rented a room in Onslow Court, Hotel, Kensington.
Leading a luxurious life, driving nice cars and gambling, Haigh needed to keep up his supply of money. By 1947, he was looking for his next target and found Dr. Archibald Henderson and Mrs. Rose Henderson. He pretended to be interested in a property they were selling and Rose invited him to their flat. Once he was at their flat, he secretly stole Mr. Henderson’s .38 caliber Webley revolver as part of his future plan.
At this point in time he had rented a tiny workshop at 2 Leopold Road, Crawley, Sussex. On February 12, 1948 he invited Mr. Henderson to his workshop on the pretext of showing him an invention. When Mr. Henderson entered the workshop, he shot him with the revolver. He then told Mrs. Henderson that her husband was ill and when she entered the workshop he shot her as well. He disposed of their bodies in the acid bath, forged a letter in their name, sold all of their possessions for 8000 pounds, keeping their dog and car.
Haigh’s last known victim was 69-year-old Olive Durand-Deacon. She lived at the Onslow Court Hotel and Haigh thought that she was a good catch as she was a wealthy widow. He posed as an engineer and on February 18, 1949, asked her to meet him at his Leopold Road workshop to discuss an idea that she had about artificial fingernails. There he shot her with the stolen revolver and robbed her of valuable items before dumping her in the acid bath.